eastern ontaWhere winds blow, storms follow

Ontario has wind power with an installed capacity of 1,636 megawatts, an amount expected to rise to 2,200 megawatts by early next year.

Voters responded by electing Peter Mertens, who campaigned against wind development, as mayor. They also transformed what had been a pro-wind council into one that passed a motion in January calling for a moratorium on wind development. About 80 municipalities have passed similar resolutions.

Its going to be a real problem for the Liberals because we can mobilize in somewhere between 24 and 26 Liberal ridings in rural areas, he says. Im quite confident that windconcerns groups can move the bar enough in enough ridings to defeat the government.

THE REALITY OF WIND POWER

Elmes iseastern ontario health unit not alone. Fertilized by generous subsidies in the Ontario governments Green Energy Act, industrial wind turbines are sprouting like dandelions across the provinces rural landscape, finding willing hosts in rmers and other property owners eager to earn some money by leasing their land.

With close to 5,000 turbines expected to sprout up in rural Ontario in the foreseeable future, a divide is growing in rural areas between those who see wind power as an economic boon to be welcomed and others who feel the technology is a threat to their health, wealth and enjoyment of life. Don Butler explains

But that was before a 100-megawatt wind rm began operating next door in December. Forty-four turbines, each more than 400 feet tall, now surround her paradisical rm on three sides. The nearest is about 1.5 kilometres from her house.

Most wind rms are in central or southwestern Ontario. There are 162 turbines in Bruce County alone, with nearly 480 more proposed. Chatham-Kent has 203 turbines, with about 430 more in the works.

Energy consultant Tom Adams, a critic of the Green Energy Act, spoke at a conference last month organized by an anti-wind group in Meaford, near Georgian Bay. Astonishingly, more than 250 people showed up on a sunny spring Saturday to hear Adams and other speakers.

Urban residents, who largely regard wind power as an unbridled virtue, might cheer that news. But in rural areas, the turbine invasion has generated anger, alarm and corrosive social division, pitting those who welcome wind power as an economic boon against those horrified by what they view as a threat to their health, wealth and enjoyment of life.

More research is required, says Lynn. But thats hampered by nondisclosure agreements imposed on leaseholders by wind companies, including clauses that forbid them from talking about problems.

There are milies in Ontario who no longer speak to each other because of this issue, says John Laforet, head of Wind Concerns Ontario, a coalition of 57 mostly rural anti-wind groups whose website has attracted nearly 1.5 million views. Its perceived that some are prepared to destroy the community in exchange for a few thousand dollars.

Elmes says she feels huge despair at whats happening. But this months announcement that Ontarios Progressive Conservatives would scrap the lucrative feed-in tariff (FIT) program for wind power projects if elected this ll gives her hope that things could change.

But Dr. Hazel Lynn, medical officer of health for the Grey Bruce Health Unit, reached a different conclusion in a report in January. Its clear, she found, that many people have been dramatically impacted by the noise and proximity of wind rms. To dismiss all these people as eccentric, unusual or hyper-sensitive social outliers does a disservice to constructive public discourse.

When Monica Elmes and her husband Neil bought their 35-hectare rm near Ridgetown in southwestern Ontario 15 years ago, the rural peace and serenity was the main attraction. It was like heaven, she says.

The islands natural heritage has taken a beating as well, Kenney says. The once-abundant deer she used to enjoy seeing have fled. The short-eared owl, a species of special concern in Canada, has all but disappeared from the islands west end.

When prospective buyers come to Prince Edward County -a mecca for former urbanites seeking a bucolic alternative -the first thing they ask real-estate agents is whether a property is near an area that may get turbines, says Mertens. If so, they arent interested.

eastern ontaWhere winds blow, storms follow,Jane Wilson, who chairs the North Gower Wind Action group, stands beside a field near her home that is slated for an eight-to-10 wind turbine project. Theyre not little windmills, she says. These ones are about 190 metres tall. Thats twice the height of the Peace Tower.

It was a huge eye-opener for me, Adams says. They are so pissed off about this. Were talkeastern ontaWhere winds blow, storms following about something really deep here -the protection of peoples land value. People get emotional about that subject.

The range of noise is unbelievable, and its all so completely different from what youre used to that you just stop whatever youre doing, Elmes says. I used to love my neighbourhood. I dont anymore.

Thats about the only thing keeping me going. We all just want our healthy, peaceful lives back.

To me, its already suspicious before you start, she says.

It sucks, says Elmes. The noise is, at times, huge. Sometimes it sounds like a pulsing jet engine. At other times, its a constant rumble, like an endless freight train passing. Neighbours tell her its like living near an airport.

Wolfe Island, across the harbour from Kingston, is home to the only wind project in Eastern Ontario. Operating for two years with 86 turbines, its the second-largest in Canada. But Kemptville-based Prowind Canada has proposed smaller projects near North Gower, Spencerville, Carleton Place and Winchester.

Wind turbines were a lively issue in last lls municipal election in pastoral Prince Edward County near Belleville, where a nine-turbine project along a major path for migratory birds is close to proceeding and numerous others are in various stages of development.

Ontario would also need 10,000 megawatts of natural gas generation as a backup for periods when wind power was producing little or nothing, Aegent said.

One of the inherent limitations of wind power is its unreliability. It produces electricity only when the wind blows. And how much it produces depends on how much oomph nature provides at any given time.

There are 914 turbines provincewide, theoretically capable of generating up to 1,636 megawatts of electricity.

Its terrible, moans Wayne Fitzgerald, mayor of the rural municipality of Grey Highlands, where a wind developer is poised to start construction on an 11-turbine project. Were torn on council, were torn in the community. The people who are opposed to it are very, very vocal. They feel quite strongly.

Jane Wilson, who chairs the North Gower Wind Action group, stands beside a field near her home that is slated for an eight-to-10 wind turbine project. Theyre not little windmills, she says. These ones are about 190 metres tall. Thats twice the height of the Peace Tower.

Coupled with the Green Energy Acts removal of local authority over the siting and approval of turbines, this cone of silence has created a huge sense of social injustice in rural Ontario, says Laforet. But the Green Energy Acts cost and ineffectiveness means urbanites are paying a high price, too, he says.

Opponents say studies have found that those living adjacent to turbines have lost between 20 and 40 per cent of their property value. In some cases, properties have become virtually unsellable.

The issue will have a profound impact on the outcome of this Octobers provincial election, predicts Laforet, whose group is actively preparing to organize against the governing Liberals.

Most health concerns are related to the noise the turbines make -particularly infrasound, a low-frequency vibration below the normal range of human hearing. Some who live near turbines report disrupted sleep, headaches, nausea, tinnitus and dizziness.

Not all people exposed to wind turbines suffer physical symptoms, Lynn said in an interview. But a certain percentage do. Thats pretty consistent across the world. Its the same complaints everywhere. And thats really rare unless theres some real reason for it.

Data showing a double-dip in home prices, pessimistic consumers and a slowdown in regional manucturing raised concerns on Tuesday that the U.S. economy…

While they cant always hear the turbines, when the wind is blowing the right way, it completely fills the atmosphere, says Gail Kenney. This is not like the noise of anything I know. The turbines pollute the night sky, she says, with red lights that flash every three seconds.

It found that the average capacity ctor over that time was 27.8 per cent, meaning that for every 1,000 megawatts of installed wind capacity, the average annual output would be 278 megawatts. But that doesnt account for winds variability. That same 1,000 megawatts would produce no electricity at all at if theres no wind, or as much as 949 megawatts in a stiff gale.

By comparison, nuclear power has an average capacity ctor of about 90 per cent. Last year, nuclear reactors produced the equivalent of a continuous, around-the-clock output of 9,452 megawatts.

To replace that nuclear output with wind power, Ontario would require 34,000 megawatts of installed wind capacity, Aegent calculated. The turbines needed for that, it said, would consume 14,200 square kilometres of land -equivalent to a band 14 kilometres wide and 1,000 kilometres long.

In a recent study, Aegent Energy Advisors evaluated wind data for 2009 and 2010 from the Ontario Independent Electricity System Operator (IESO), which measures the output of wind turbines connected to the high voltage distribution grid.

Mertens had an e-mail recently from a property owner whos been trying to sell a lot near one of the proposed projects for two years, without success. He told me hes walking away from the lot now. He no longer wants to pay taxes on it.

That said, the health impact of turbines has yet to be conclusively demonstrated. In a May 2010 report, Ontarios chief medical officer of health, Dr. Arlene King, found that scientific evidence to date does not demonstrate a direct causal link between wind turbine noise and adverse health effects.

They put their hearts and souls into renovating the old rmhouse. We did that thinking wed never have to consider leaving.

It became an extremely divisive issue, and it has probably gotten worse, if anything, Mertens says. Urbanites who fled to the county to enjoy its scenic beauty have found themselves at odds with longtime rm residents who see the turbines as a way to generate needed cash.

For opponents, the sheer scale of the turbines is only part of it. There are also concerns about their impact on health and property values.

dbutler@ottawacitizen.com

But in ct, it produces r less than that. Friday morning between 8 and 9 a.m., for example, wind was generating just 31 megawatts of electricity. Between 11 a.m. and noon on Wednesday, when winds were blowing more lustily, it was cranking out 669 megawatts.

Opponents have mobilized. The North Gower Wind Action group, formed to fight a proposed eight-to-10-turbine project near the village, has about 300 supporters. These are industrial structures, says Jane Wilson, the groups chair. Theyre not little windmills. These ones are about 190 metres tall. Thats twice the height of the Peace Tower.

The province already has signed contracts with wind companies that will roughly double that number. And it has received applications for a further 3,000 or so turbines, with an installed capacity of 6,672 megawatts, according to the Canadian Wind Energy Association.

A tax assessment hearing now under way could help provide some clarity on the issue. Gail and Edward Kenney are arguing that the 28 turbines they can see from their home on Wolfe Island have devalued their property.

Within the foreseeable future, in short, close to 5,000 wind turbines could blanket rural Ontario.

We see it as a battle all Ontarians are in, because we all lose. We all have to pay more for this power we dont need. But in rural Ontario, they lose so much more. They lose their way of life, they lose their property values and, in some cases, they lose their health.

Leave a Reply